Citizens' Oversight Maryland---Maryland Progressives
CINDY WALSH FOR MAYOR OF BALTIMORE----SOCIAL DEMOCRAT
Citizens Oversight Maryland.com
  • Home
  • Cindy Walsh for Mayor of Baltimore
    • Mayoral Election violations
    • Questionnaires from Community >
      • Education Questionnaire
      • Baltimore Housing Questionnaire
      • Emerging Youth Questionnaire
      • Health Care policy for Baltimore
      • Environmental Questionnaires
      • Livable Baltimore questionnaire
      • Labor Questionnnaire
      • Ending Food Deserts Questionnaire
      • Maryland Out of School Time Network
      • LBGTQ Questionnaire
      • Citizen Artist Baltimore Mayoral Forum on Arts & Culture Questionnaire
      • Baltimore Transit Choices Questionnaire
      • Baltimore Activating Solidarity Economies (BASE)
      • Downtown Partnership Questionnaire
      • The Northeast Baltimore Communities Of BelAir Edison Community Association (BECCA )and Frankford Improvement Association, Inc. (FIA)
      • Streets and Transportation/Neighbood Questionnaire
      • African American Tourism and business questionnaire
      • Baltimore Sun Questionnaire
      • City Paper Mayoral Questionnaire
      • Baltimore Technology Com Questionnaire
      • Baltimore Biker's Questionnair
      • Homewood Friends Meeting Questionnaire
      • Baltimore Historical Collaboration---Anthem Project
      • Tubman City News Mayoral Questionnaire
      • Maryland Public Policy Institute Questionnaire
      • AFRO questionnaire
      • WBAL Candidate's Survey
  • Blog
  • Trans Pacific Pact (TPP)
  • Progressive vs. Third Way Corporate Democrats
    • Third Way Think Tanks
  • Financial Reform/Wall Street Fraud
    • Consumer Financial Protection Bureau >
      • CFPB Actions
    • Voted to Repeal Glass-Steagall
    • Federal Reserve >
      • Federal Reserve Actions
    • Securities and Exchange Commission >
      • SEC Actions
    • Commodity Futures Trading Commission >
      • CFTC Actions
    • Office of the Comptroller of the Currency >
      • OCC Actions
    • Office of Treasury/ Inspector General for the Treasury
    • FINRA >
      • FINRA ACTIONS
  • Federal Healthcare Reform
    • Health Care Fraud in the US
    • Health and Human Services Actions
  • Social Security and Entitlement Reform
    • Medicare/Medicaid/SCHIP Actions
  • Federal Education Reform
    • Education Advocates
  • Government Schedules
    • Baltimore City Council
    • Maryland State Assembly >
      • Budget and Taxation Committee
    • US Congress
  • State and Local Government
    • Baltimore City Government >
      • City Hall Actions
      • Baltimore City Council >
        • Baltimore City Council Actions
      • Baltimore Board of Estimates meeting >
        • Board of Estimates Actions
    • Governor's Office >
      • Telling the World about O'Malley
    • Lt. Governor Brown
    • Maryland General Assembly Committees >
      • Communications with Maryland Assembly
      • Budget and Taxation Committees >
        • Actions
        • Pension news
      • Finance Committees >
        • Schedule
      • Business Licensing and Regulation
      • Judicial, Rules, and Nominations Committee
      • Education, Health, and Environmental Affairs Committee >
        • Committee Actions
    • Maryland State Attorney General >
      • Open Meetings Act
      • Maryland Courts >
        • Maryland Court System
    • States Attorney - Baltimore's Prosecutor
    • State Comptroller's Office >
      • Maryland Business Tax Reform >
        • Business Tax Reform Issues
  • Maryland Committee Actions
    • Board of Public Works >
      • Public Works Actions
    • Maryland Public Service Commission >
      • Public Meetings
    • Maryland Health Care Commission/Maryland Community Health Resources Commission >
      • MHCC/MCHRC Actions
    • Maryland Consumer Rights Coalition
  • Maryland and Baltimore Development Organizations
    • Baltimore/Maryland Development History
    • Committee Actions
    • Maryland Development Organizations
  • Maryland State Department of Education
    • Charter Schools
    • Public Schools
    • Algebra Project Award
  • Baltimore City School Board
    • Charter Schools >
      • Charter Schools---Performance
      • Charter School Issues
    • Public Schools >
      • Public School Issues
  • Progressive Issues
    • Fair and Balanced Elections
    • Labor Issues
    • Rule of Law Issues >
      • Rule of Law
    • Justice issues 2
    • Justice Issues
    • Progressive Tax Reform Issues >
      • Maryland Tax Reform Issues
      • Baltimore Tax Reform Issues
    • Strong Public Education >
      • Corporate education reform organizations
    • Healthcare for All Issues >
      • Universal Care Bill by state
  • Building Strong Media
    • Media with a Progressive Agenda (I'm still checking on that!) >
      • anotherangryvoice.blogspot.com
      • "Talk About It" Radio - WFBR 1590AM Baltimore
      • Promethius Radio Project
      • Clearing the Fog
      • Democracy Now
      • Black Agenda Radio
      • World Truth. TV Your Alternative News Network.
      • Daily Censured
      • Bill Moyers Journal
      • Center for Public Integrity
      • Public Radio International
      • Baltimore Brew
      • Free Press
    • Far Left/Socialist Media
    • Media with a Third Way Agenda >
      • MSNBC
      • Center for Media and Democracy
      • Public Radio and TV >
        • NPR and MPT News
      • TruthOut
  • Progressive Organizations
    • Political Organizations >
      • Progressives United
      • Democracy for America
    • Labor Organizations >
      • United Workers
      • Unite Here Local 7
      • ROC-NY works to build power and win justice
    • Justice Organizations >
      • APC Baltimore
      • Occupy Baltimore
    • Rule of Law Organizations >
      • Bill of Rights Defense Committee
      • National Lawyers Guild
      • National ACLU
    • Tax Reform Organizations
    • Healthcare for All Organizations >
      • Healthcare is a Human Right - Maryland
      • PNHP Physicians for a National Health Program
      • Healthcare NOW- Maryland
    • Public Education Organizations >
      • Parents Across America
      • Philadelphia Public School Notebook thenotebook.org
      • Chicago Teachers Union/Blog
      • Ed Wize Blog
      • Educators for a Democratic Union
      • Big Education Ape
    • Elections Organizations >
      • League of Women Voters
  • Progressive Actions
    • Labor Actions
    • Justice Actions
    • Tax Reform Actions >
      • Baltimore Tax Actions
      • Maryland Tax Reform Actions
    • Healthcare Actions
    • Public Education Actions
    • Rule of Law Actions >
      • Suing Federal and State government
    • Free and Fair Elections Actions
  • Maryland/Baltimore Voting Districts - your politicians and their votes
    • 2014 ELECTION OF STATE OFFICES
    • Maryland Assembly/Baltimore
  • Petitions, Complaints, and Freedom of Information Requests
    • Complaints - Government and Consumer >
      • Sample Complaints
    • Petitions >
      • Sample Petitions
    • Freedom of Information >
      • Sample Letters
  • State of the Democratic Party
  • Misc
    • WBFF TV
    • WBAL TV
    • WJZ TV
    • WMAR TV
    • WOLB Radio---Radio One
    • The Gazette
    • Baltimore Sun Media Group
  • Misc 2
    • Maryland Public Television
    • WYPR
    • WEAA
    • Maryland Reporter
  • Misc 3
    • University of Maryland
    • Morgan State University
  • Misc 4
    • Baltimore Education Coalition
    • BUILD Baltimore
    • Church of the Great Commission
    • Maryland Democratic Party
    • Pennsylvania Avenue AME Zion Church
    • Maryland Municipal League
    • Maryland League of Women Voters
  • Untitled
  • Untitled
  • Standard of Review
  • Untitled
  • WALSH FOR GOVERNOR - CANDIDATE INFORMATION AND PLATFORM
    • Campaign Finance/Campaign donations
    • Speaking Events
    • Why Heather Mizeur is NOT a progressive
    • Campaign responses to Community Organization Questionnaires
    • Cindy Walsh vs Maryland Board of Elections >
      • Leniency from court for self-representing plaintiffs
      • Amended Complaint
      • Plaintiff request for expedited trial date
      • Response to Motion to Dismiss--Brown, Gansler, Mackie, and Lamone
      • Injunction and Mandamus
      • DECISION/APPEAL TO SPECIAL COURT OF APPEALS---Baltimore City Circuit Court response to Cindy Walsh complaint >
        • Brief for Maryland Court of Special Appeals >
          • Cover Page ---yellow
          • Table of Contents
          • Table of Authorities
          • Leniency for Pro Se Representation
          • Statement of Case
          • Questions Presented
          • Statement of Facts
          • Argument
          • Conclusion/Font and Type Size
          • Record Extract
          • Appendix
          • Motion for Reconsideration
          • Response to Defendants Motion to Dismiss
          • Motion to Reconsider Dismissal
      • General Election fraud and recount complaints
    • Cindy Walsh goes to Federal Court for Maryland election violations >
      • Complaints filed with the FCC, the IRS, and the FBI
      • Zapple Doctrine---Media Time for Major Party candidates
      • Complaint filed with the US Justice Department for election fraud and court irregularities.
      • US Attorney General, Maryland Attorney General, and Maryland Board of Elections are charged with enforcing election law
      • Private media has a responsibility to allow access to all candidates in an election race. >
        • Print press accountable to false statement of facts
      • Polling should not determine a candidate's viability especially if the polling is arbitrary
      • Viability of a candidate
      • Public media violates election law regarding do no damage to candidate's campaign
      • 501c3 Organizations violate election law in doing no damage to a candidate in a race >
        • 501c3 violations of election law-----private capital
      • Voter apathy increases when elections are not free and fair
  • Maryland Board of Elections certifies election on July 10, 2014
  • Maryland Elections ---2016

July 10th, 2012

7/10/2012

0 Comments

 
 I READ THE ASSESSMENT TOOLS UMUC HAS ADOPTED TO EVALUATE ITS PROGRESS AND I STOPPED RIGHT AT THE BEGINNING WHEN I READ THE ALABAMA-BASED ASSESSMENT TOOL WAS A MODEL.  WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT ALABAMA AND EDUCATION?  THAT'S RIGHT.  WHO GETS TO ATTEND THESE CORPORATIZED STATE UNIVERSITIES?  OVERSEAS MILITARY TROOPS USING UP THEIR MILITARY BENEFITS ON TRASH EDUCATION, NGOs PARTNERING WITH FOREIGN GOVERNMENTS FOR HOMELAND SECURITY/CIA TYPE TRAINING.  TAXPAYER'S EDUCATION MONEY IS FLOWING INTO THESE PROGRAMS THAT ARE JUST LIKE THE FOR-PROFIT MODELS FULL OF FRAUD AND O'MALLEY TOTES EXPANDING NUMBERS OF STUDENTS AND RANKINGS GIVEN BY THE SAME PEOPLE PROMOTING THIS JUNK.

IT IS HARD IN MARYLAND TO FIND CRITICISM OF ANYTHING BECAUSE THERE IS NO TRANSPARENCY, BUT BELOW I WAS ABLE TO FIND CURRENT ASSESSMENTS FROM STAFF AND PROFESSIONALS NOT BOUND TO SILENCE.  MOSTLY ADJUNCT PROFESSORS WITH NO VOICE BEING INCREASINGLY PUSHED INTO MORE 'EFFICIENT' MODES OF TEACHING, TURNOVER AT A MAXIMUM, STUDENTS PUSHED INTO EVER-SHORTER CLASSES, AND FALLING QUALITY......ALL THE SIGNS OF PRIVATIZING.  THESE ARE STUDENTS FROM MIDDLE/LOWER CLASS FAMILIES WHO ARE TAKING THIS ROUTE BECAUSE THEY CAN'T AFFORD THE U OF MD COLLEGE PARK EXPERIENCE.  THIS IS TIERED EDUCATION AT ITS PEAK AND IT IS WHAT THEY ARE TRYING TO DO TO OUR K-12 RIGHT NOW.

VOTE YOUR INCUMBENT OUT OF OFFICE!!!!!

Dangers of Depleted Morale
February 28, 2012 - 3:00am By Kevin Kiley

Inside Higher Ed

Faculty members at the University of Maryland University College – whose president, Susan C. Aldridge, was placed on indefinite administrative leave last week – have repeatedly expressed dissatisfaction with the university’s administration, raising concerns about pay, shared governance, and professors' views that the administration lacked interest in academic standards.

When they received no response from the university's administration, based in Adelphi, Md., they took their concerns to the University System of Maryland, which oversees the institution and 11 other public universities in Maryland. In November 2010, faculty members in the university’s Asian division, which serves students in Japan, Korea, and Guam, sent a letter to William E. (Brit) Kirwan, the system’s chancellor, highlighting the findings of a survey they conducted among themselves.

“The attached faculty survey is a de facto vote of no confidence in the present administration,” wrote Mervin B. Whealy, a former member of the Faculty Advisory Council representing the Asian division, who wrote the cover letter to the survey. “Issues that have degraded faculty morale in Asia include the declining economic value of UMUC employment, a lack of shared governance, problems associated with the appointment of the next Asian Director, the Aldridge administration’s insufficient interest in academics, and the management of the Asian division and Adelphi.”

The University System of Maryland has not yet offered an explanation for why Aldridge was placed on leave. UMUC faculty members do not have tenure, so those asked to comment declined to speak on the record or be quoted. Several said they do not think faculty complaints were the reason Aldridge was placed on leave, since the complaints have been on the books for a while and the system has shown no hint of action until last week.

UMUC is one of the largest public universities, serving more than 90,000 students in the U.S., Europe, and Asia, including many active military personnel. It has grown significantly in the past two decades. In 2000, the university reported that it enrolled 71,560 students. In 2011, it reported that it enrolled 96,342. Many of these students are part-time, so the full-time equivalent enrollment is about 32,000.

UMUC has often been held up as a model of how public higher education can take advantage of tools often employed by for-profit institutions – such as online education and sped-up course schedules – to reach a group of nontraditional students that four-year, residential campuses rarely do. The survey from Asia and other complaints from faculty members in the United States show that the university’s notable gains haven’t been made without some resistance from faculty members and that problems have existed beneath the surface for several years.

A spokesman for the University System of Maryland said there has been no public airing of the issues raised by the survey, and that any concern about the manner in which an employee has conducted his or her duties is a personnel matter and therefore confidential.

The survey was sent to 104 faculty members in the Asian division, and 53 of those faculty members responded -- a fraction of the university’s total of about 2,200 faculty members. The overwhelming majority of UMUC faculty members work for the institution part-time.

Rating their morale on a scale from one to 10, with 10 being the highest morale, more than half of the survey respondents said their morale was a three or lower.



The issues that most faculty members said contributed to low morale were tied to compensation, including a lack of raises in the previous three years; the currency-adjustment formula; and their housing allowance.

“Morale is low in the Asian division because the administration seems to have little regard for our economic condition and basically gives us the choice of ‘quitting’ if we do not like these conditions,” one survey respondent wrote. “We need some encouraging word about their intentions regarding our economic condition in the future.”

Many respondents also said administrative turnover, academic issues, and a lack of shared governance were factors in the low morale. “At UMUC, shared governance has little practical meaning,” Whealy wrote in the letter. “When the Asian faculty sent a letter to Dr. Aldridge in 2010, expressing concerns about its degraded financial condition, she did not respond.”

Responses to open-ended questions throughout the survey decried the university’s top-down leadership style. Respondents said the administration was not open to input from faculty members, even on questions of academics, where faculty members at most traditional colleges and universities tend to exert significant authority. They also complained about the departure of several administrators whom faculty respected.

“The mysterious firings and resignations of competent [administrators] tell us that the integrity and high standards of our university are not a priority in Adelphi,” one respondent wrote, referring to the university's headquarters. “When our best advocates leave, and cannot tell us why – something is very wrong. It harms morale and increases distrust of administrative policies.”

Faculty members outside the Asian division have also complained about the university’s rapid embrace of technology and course restructuring over the last five years, which have placed an increased workload on them while, in their opinion, diminishing the quality of the education offered, faculty members said.

The university has moved quickly to reformat classes to make better use of online technologies and to transform the schedule. Classes have been pared down from 14 weeks to eight weeks to make offerings more flexible, particularly to accommodate military personnel who often don’t have a full 14 weeks to take a class.


UMUC Jun 10, 2012
2012-06-10 22:46 PDT 

Compensation & Benefits 4.0
Career Opportunities 1.0
 Senior Leadership 1.0
Culture & Values 1.0
 Work/Life Balance 4.0

 UMUC Adjunct Faculty:   (Past Employee - 2012)

“
Horrible Diploma Mill”  
Pros

* Pay is slightly above market rate.
* Work to be done is simple grading and very limited conference postings.

Cons

* Course material is laughably thin, poorly presented, and frequently factually incorrect.
* Infrastructure for providing online courses is a decade or more out of date.
* Facilities for managing the course are not available to adjuncts, despite the apparent fact the major investments have been made in facilitating and automating the needs of higher level administrators.
* Management provides no meaningful professional development, and mainly communicates through threats.
* Grading instructions to adjunct explicitly and expressly violate grading policies published to the students.
* Administrations is hostile to even obvious suggestions about improving course content, and responds to such suggestions by closing down avenues for public communication.
* No meaningful enrollment standard means most students are completely unprepared to do meaningful coursework.

Advice to Senior Management

Collect as much cash as you can now, because eventually the military will look into why so many of its personal are so poorly educated.

UMUC Transcript Evaluator in Adelphi, MD:   (Current Employee)

“
Culture of ineptness, academic integrity last thing considered” Pros

Good state university system benefits.
Pay scale average.

Cons

Poor communication from upper management.
Agree with 'fear-based management' assessment
minimal adherence to accreditable standards when putting together degree plans
definitely becoming a diploma mill
lack of openness to innovation at all levels. management especially defensive and not open-minded to criticism, concerns, or new ideas, even when they assert they are.
employees looked down upon, even those with professional degrees.

  • UMUC has been protected in the shadow of the University of Maryland for years, including getting the benefit of doubt with the most positive spin one could hope for? To wit: "The university has moved quickly to reformat classes to make better use
    of online technologies and to transform the schedule. Classes have been
    pared down from 14 weeks to eight weeks to make offerings more flexible,
    particularly to accommodate military personnel who often don’t have a
    full 14 weeks to take a class." How exactly is "paring down", except when applied to one's girth, an improvement in the quality and substance? While someone is researching this, you might want to look a bit more deeply at the "life experience" credits UMUC has expanded into robust marketing approach that has historically been a favorite methodology of diploma mills. Maryland deserves better than this, as do the tens of thousands of military personnel all over the world.
  • Faculty 4 months ago in reply to RJW74
  •  In addition to reducing semesters to 8 weeks they also eliminated proctored final exams.
    Both of these decisions came as directives with no input from faculty or the students from President Aldridge and Dean Cini.


  • MGWade 4 months ago in reply to RJW74  While the erosion of academic standards, particularly via on-line courses, is nationwide, what is going on at my alma mater has the odor of fraudulence about it.  The university, service personnel and the taxpayers all deserve better than this.  I wonder if  the "paring down" is a response to complaints, retention pressures, and a desire to protect the huge market that UM has garnered.  If so, there is a serious problem of values here.  Class of '68.
  • Faculty 4 months ago
  • The UMUC administrators made two far- reaching decisions this past year WITHOUT any faculty or student input for the stateside campus:
    1. They reduced the length of every course to 8 weeks! This is overwhelming students because faculty are teaching twice as much content each week. Faculty were given no reason for the change and were informed by email that it was to happen as of the Fall 2011 semester.
    2. Just a couple of weeks before the Fall semester was to begin, the Dean of the undergraduate school (she is still at UMUC so far) sent an email informing faculty that UMUC will no longer offer proctored final exams. Again, we were given no explanation. Faculty were shocked and are still trying to figure out how to have some semblance of exam integrity given this reckless decision.
    There are many top level administrators at UMUC who should be investigated. I won't be surprised to see more of them in the unemployment line.
    These comments apply to the stateside programs only.

    _______________________________________________
  • O'MALLEY CONSTANTLY USES 'EDUCATION WEEK' AND ITS RATING OF MARYLAND AS #1 IN EDUCATION.  WELL, EDUCATION WEEK IS A CORPORATE EDUCATION JOURNAL FUNDED IN PART BY BILL GATES....THE SOURCE OF THE PRIVATIZING PUSH ON PUBLIC EDUCATION.  YOU CAN SEE ABOVE THAT MOST CLAIM TO FAME OF MARYLAND'S UNIVERSITIES COME FROM SPIN AND SELF-AGGRANDIZEMENT.  WE ARE SEEING GOOD STATE UNIVERSITIES TURNED INTO DIPLOMA MILLS WITH GLOBAL EXPANSIONS THAT HAVE FOREIGN COUNTRIES RUNNING FROM AMERICAN EDUCATION .......THEY PREFER EUROPEAN EDUCATION TO US EDUCATION BECAUSE THESE CORPORATE RAIDERS HAVE GUTTED QUALITY FOR QUANTITY.........
    Diane Ravitch's blog
  • A site to discuss better education for all « Who Is Funding Charters? More about Stand for Children in Memphis » I Am Puzzled by the Gates Foundation July 5, 2012 // 100 When one foundation has amassed over $30 billion, it has the financial power to shape the policies of government to its liking.

    The Gates Foundation has more than $30 billion, and when Warren Buffet’s gift of another $30 billion is added to the Gates fund, the Gates Foundation will have the power to direct global policy on almost any issue of its choosing.

    Anthony Cody published
    a guest column in Education Week (funded in part by the Gates Foundation) that describes how the Gates Foundation intervenes in agricultural and environmental issues around the world, often in ways that support corporate profits rather than the public interest.

    I have never believed that the Gates Foundation or the Gates family puts profits above the public interest. I work on the assumption that anyone who has more riches than they can ever spend in their lifetime or in 100 lifetimes is not motivated by greed. It makes no sense.

    I believe that Bill and Melinda Gates want to establish a legacy as people who left the world a better place.

    But I think their their efforts to “reform” education are woefully mistaken.

    I have tried but had no luck in my efforts to meet Bill Gates. On the two occasions when I was in Seattle in the past year, I tried to arrange a meeting with him well in advance. He was never available.

    I am puzzled by what I read in the column cited here. I am also puzzled by the Gates Foundation’s persistent funding of groups that want to privatize public education. I am puzzled by their funding of “astroturf” groups of young teachers who insist that they don’t want any job protections, don’t want to be rewarded for their experience (of which they have little) or for any additional degrees, and certainly don’t want to be represented by a collective bargaining unit.

    I am puzzled by their funding of groups that are promoting an anti-teacher, anti-public education agenda in state after state. And I am puzzled by the hundreds of millions they have poured into the quixotic search to guarantee that every single classroom has a teacher that knows how to raise test scores.

    Sometimes I wonder if anyone at the Gates Foundation has any vision of what good education is, or whether they think that getting higher test scores is the same as getting a good education. I wonder if they ever think about their role in demoralizing and destabilizing the education profession.

    When Bill or Melinda Gates is asked whether it is democratic for one foundation, their foundation, to shape a nation’s education policy, they don a mask of false modesty. Who, little old us? They disingenuously reply that the nation spends more than $600 billion on education, which makes their own contribution small by comparison. Puny, by comparison. Anyone with any sense knows that their discretionary spending has had a powerful effect on the policies of the U.S. Department of Education, on the media, on states and on districts. When Bill Gates speaks, the National Governors Association snaps to attention, awed by his wealth. They are pulling the strings, and they prefer to pretend they aren’t.

    But their disclaimers do not change the fact that they have power without accountability. They want accountability for teachers, but who holds them accountable?

    When I see Bill or Melinda make a pronouncement on education, I am reminded of the song in “Fiddler on the Roof”: “When you’re rich, they think you really know.”

    They don’t. And no one will tell them that they are out of their depth. They may be well-meaning but they are misinformed, and they are inflicting incalculable damage on our public schools and on the education profession.

    Who elected them? Why should they have the power to shape American education?.

    It’s puzzling.


    ______________________________________________
  • IT IS IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND THAT THIS UNDERMINING OF EDUCATION FOR THE MIDDLE/LOWER CLASSES IS HAPPENING IN UK AS WELL......AS WITH THE MASSIVE FRAUDS....THE 1% IN THE US AND THE UK ARE WORKING HARD TO MARGINALIZE ALL OF US.


    The privatisation of higher education is forcing out poorer students Tuition fees and the government's marketisation of universities mean that bright working class students will no longer apply
  • Michael Chessum
  • guardian.co.uk, Tuesday 10 July 2012 05.10 EDT
  • ~
  • Yesterday, the University and Colleges Admissions Service (Ucas) announced a sharp drop in the number of university applicants for the first year of £9,000 fees. The official government narrative – that the 9% drop is merely a readjustment for a similar rise in applications for places before the fee rise – is paper thin. In fact, ministers have offered no serious explanation or sense of reflection at all. Most crucially, no analysis has been offered as to who has chosen not to apply, or why.

    The reality, as major studies have suggested ever since tuition fees were introduced, is that rocketing tuition fees have pushed bright students from working-class backgrounds away from university.

    This is supported by the fact that the biggest drop to occur is among people over the age of 23 – often among the most disadvantaged set of applicants. These mature students are not the Willetts fantasy of "ill-informed" 18-year-olds, failing to understand that debt repayments are income-linked. The fact is that the government is in the process of creating a system driven by consumer choice, in which the rational money-driven decision could be never to apply to university.

    The only possible result of this process will be fewer people going to university, or, to put it more accurately, fewer working-class people going to university. For those not fortunate enough to get good grades at a nice secondary school, a degree in some subjects, costing £27,000 before living costs, will result in a net earning loss over your lifetime. Education as a life-enhancing, horizon-broadening experience – even if only inadvertently and in passing – is being snatched away, both by the ideology of the system, and now by debt and post-graduation data.

    Even without this process, the result of the government's programme for education will be the systematic exclusion of many of Britain's less affluent prospective students. The market system – put in motion by Labour's introduction of fees and moved to its logical conclusion by the coalition's higher education white paper – will starve newer universities of teaching grants, concentrating wealth into the hands of whatever the market, regulated by the Research Excellence Framework (REF) and mechanisms like it, decides is best.

    A quiet cull of "unprofitable" courses has been taking place for some time: students at London Met, Britain's most working-class university, have lost their history and philosophy departments. A report released by the UCU this year found that the number of courses on offer in England has declined by almost a third in four years.

    On the surface, course cuts, fees and marketisation, not to mention the abolition of EMA, appear to be the betrayal of a generation; but in truth they stem from a deeper and more typical Tory agenda. The 9% drop in applicants will not be from the sons and daughters of government ministers, whose parents can pay, or whose knowledge of the system and schooling means that they can be assured that university will be a sound investment, not a financial nightmare.

    Equally, the winners from the white paper, if there are winners at all, will be "world class" and research-intensive universities. Fees and marketisation may yet boost the global prestige of a handful of Britain's universities, and the collective ego of the likes of universities minister David Willetts and the vice chancellors who inform his thinking, but their broader social implications will be a disaster for the vast majority of ordinary people.

    The latest Ucas data is not at its root a lesson in students getting the "wrong information", or the fact that the government's reform programme is often chaotic and dysfunctional, which it is. The truth is that the reforms are having broadly the desired effect: higher education is shrinking and increasingly being privatised, and different tiers of learning are developing – some for the elite, and some for the rest.

    The key question as students and trade unions prepare for another autumn of discontent will be "who pays?", and when Ucas releases reports on student numbers, attention is focused on fees. This narrative is in part correct, but if education and other evaporating public services are to be saved, we must also be clear that student numbers are more than statistics; they are the symptoms of a rapidly accelerating class war.



    • Follow Comment is free on Twitter @commentisfree

  • 0 Comments

    Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


    Leave a Reply.

      Author

      Cindy Walsh is a lifelong political activist and academic living in Baltimore, Maryland.

      Archives

      April 2019
      March 2019
      February 2019
      January 2019
      December 2018
      November 2018
      October 2018
      September 2018
      August 2018
      July 2018
      June 2018
      May 2018
      April 2018
      March 2018
      February 2018
      January 2018
      December 2017
      November 2017
      October 2017
      September 2017
      August 2017
      July 2017
      June 2017
      May 2017
      April 2017
      March 2017
      February 2017
      January 2017
      December 2016
      November 2016
      October 2016
      September 2016
      August 2016
      July 2016
      June 2016
      May 2016
      April 2016
      March 2016
      February 2016
      January 2016
      December 2015
      November 2015
      October 2015
      September 2015
      August 2015
      July 2015
      June 2015
      May 2015
      April 2015
      March 2015
      February 2015
      January 2015
      December 2014
      November 2014
      October 2014
      September 2014
      August 2014
      July 2014
      June 2014
      May 2014
      April 2014
      March 2014
      February 2014
      January 2014
      December 2013
      November 2013
      October 2013
      September 2013
      August 2013
      July 2013
      June 2013
      May 2013
      April 2013
      March 2013
      February 2013
      January 2013
      December 2012
      November 2012
      October 2012
      September 2012
      August 2012
      July 2012
      June 2012
      May 2012
      April 2012

      Categories

      All
      2014 Economic Crash
      21st Century Economy
      Affordable Care Act
      Affordable Care Act
      Alec
      Americorp/VISTA
      Anthony Brown
      Anthony Brown
      Anti Incumbant
      Anti-incumbant
      Anti Incumbent
      Anti Incumbent
      Attacking The Post Office Union
      Baltimore And Cronyism
      Baltimore Board Of Estimates
      Baltimore Board Of Estimates
      Baltimore Development Corp
      Baltimore Development Corp
      Baltimore Recall/Retroactive Term Limits
      Bank Fraud
      Bank Fraud
      Bank Of America
      Bank Settlement
      Bank-settlement
      B Corporations
      Bgeexelon Mergerf59060c411
      Brookings Institution
      Business Tax Credits
      California Charter Expansion
      Cardin
      Career Colleges
      Career Colleges Replacing Union Apprenticeships
      Charters
      Charter School
      Collection Agencies
      Common Core
      Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
      Consumer-financial-protection-bureau
      Corporate Media
      Corporate-media
      Corporate Oversight
      Corporate-oversight
      Corporate Politicians
      Corporate-politicians
      Corporate Rule
      Corporate-rule
      Corporate Taxes
      Corporate-taxes
      Corporate Tax Reform
      Corporatizing Us Universities
      Cost-benefit-analysis
      Credit Crisis
      Credit-crisis
      Cummings
      Department Of Education
      Department Of Justice
      Department-of-justice
      Derivatives Reform
      Development
      Dismantling Public Justice
      Dodd Frank
      Doddfrankbba4ff090a
      Doug Gansler
      Doug-gansler
      Ebdi
      Education Funding
      Education Reform
      Edwards
      Election Reform
      Election-reform
      Elections
      Emigration
      Energy-sector-consolidation-in-maryland
      Enterprise Zones
      Equal Access
      Estate Taxes
      European Crisis
      Expanded And Improved Medicare For All
      Expanded-and-improved-medicare-for-all
      Failure To Prosecute
      Failure-to-prosecute
      Fair
      Fair And Balanced Elections
      Fair-and-balanced-elections
      Farm Bill
      Federal Election Commissionelection Violationsmaryland
      Federal Election Commissionelection Violationsmarylandd20a348918
      Federal-emergency-management-agency-fema
      Federal Reserve
      Financial Reform Bill
      Food Safety Not In Tpp
      For Profit Education
      Forprofit-education
      Fracking
      Fraud
      Freedom Of Press And Speech
      Frosh
      Gambling In Marylandbaltimore8dbce1f7d2
      Granting Agencies
      Greening Fraud
      Gun Control Policy
      Healthcare For All
      Healthcare-for-all
      Health Enterprise Zones
      High Speed Rail
      Hoyer
      Imf
      Immigration
      Incarceration Bubble
      Incumbent
      Incumbents
      Innovation Centers
      Insurance Industry Leverage And Fraud
      International Criminal Court
      International Trade Deals
      International-trade-deals
      Jack Young
      Jack-young
      Johns Hopkins
      Johns-hopkins
      Johns Hopkins Medical Systems
      Johns-hopkins-medical-systems
      Kaliope Parthemos
      Labor And Justice Law Under Attack
      Labor And Wages
      Lehmann Brothers
      Living Wageunionspolitical Action0e39f5c885
      Maggie McIntosh
      Maggie-mcintosh
      Martin O'Malley
      Martin O'Malley
      Martin-omalley
      Martin-omalley8ecd6b6eb0
      Maryland Health Co Ops
      Maryland-health-co-ops
      Maryland-health-co-ops1f77692967
      Maryland Health Coopsccd73554da
      Maryland Judiciary
      Marylandnonprofits
      Maryland Non Profits
      Maryland Nonprofits2509c2ca2c
      Maryland Public Service Commission
      Maryland State Bar Association
      Md Credit Bondleverage Debt441d7f3605
      Media
      Media Bias
      Media-bias
      Medicaremedicaid
      Medicaremedicaid8416fd8754
      Mental Health Issues
      Mental-health-issues
      Mers Fraud
      Mikulski
      Military Privatization
      Minority Unemploymentunion And Labor Wagebaltimore Board Of Estimates4acb15e7fa
      Municipal Debt Fraud
      Ndaa-indefinite-detention
      Ndaaindefinite Detentiond65cc4283d
      Net Neutrality
      New Economy
      New-economy
      Ngo
      Non Profit To Profit
      Nonprofit To Profitb2d6cb4b41
      Nsa
      O'Malley
      Odette Ramos
      Omalley
      O'Malley
      Open Meetings
      Osha
      Patronage
      Pension-benefit-guaranty-corp
      Pension Funds
      Pension-funds
      Police Abuse
      Private-and-public-pension-fraud
      Private Health Systemsentitlementsprofits Over People
      Private Health Systemsentitlementsprofits Over People6541f468ae
      Private Non Profits
      Private-non-profits
      Private Nonprofits50b33fd8c2
      Privatizing Education
      Privatizing Government Assets
      Privatizing-the-veterans-admin-va
      Privitizing Public Education
      Progressive Policy
      Progressive Taxes Replace Regressive Policy
      Protections Of The People
      Protections-of-the-people
      Public Education
      Public Funding Of Private Universities
      Public Housing Privatization
      Public-libraries-privatized-or-closed
      Public Private Partnerships
      Public-private-partnerships
      Public Transportation Privatization
      Public Utilities
      Rapid Bus Network
      Rawlings Blake
      Rawlings-blake
      Rawlingsblake1640055471
      Real Progressives
      Reit-real-estate-investment-trusts
      Reitreal Estate Investment Trustsa1a18ad402
      Repatriation Taxes
      Rule Of Law
      Rule-of-law
      Ruppersberger
      SAIC AND INTERNATIONAL SECURITY
      Sarbanes
      S Corp Taxes
      Selling Public Datapersonal Privacy
      Smart Meters
      Snowden
      Social Security
      Sovereign Debt Fraudsubprime Mortgage Fraudmortgage Fraud Settlement
      Sovereign Debt Fraudsubprime Mortgage Fraudmortgage Fraud Settlement0d62c56e69
      Statistics As Spin
      Statistics-as-spin
      Student-corps
      Subprime Mortgage Fraud
      Subprime-mortgage-fraud
      Surveillance And Security
      Sustainability
      Teachers
      Teachers Unions2bc448afc8
      Teach For America
      Teach For America
      Technology Parks
      Third Way Democrats/new Economy/public Union Employees/public Private Patnerships/government Fraud And Corruption
      Third Way Democratsnew Economypublic Union Employeespublic Private Patnershipsgovernment Fraud And Corruption
      Third-way-democratsnew-economypublic-union-employeespublic-private-patnershipsgovernment-fraud-and-corruptionc10a007aee
      Third Way/neo Liberals
      Third-wayneo-liberals
      Third-wayneo-liberals5e1e6d4716
      Third Wayneoliberals7286dda6aa
      Tifcorporate Tax Breaks2d87bba974
      Tpp
      Transportation Inequity In Maryland
      Union Busting
      Unionbusting0858fddb8b
      Unions
      Unionsthird Waypost Officealec3c887e7815
      Universities
      Unreliable Polling
      Unreliable-polling
      Van Hollen
      Van-hollen
      VEOLA Environment -privatization Of Public Water
      Veterans
      War Against Women And Children
      War-against-women-and-children
      Youth Works

      RSS Feed

    Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.